Global: VyStar Credit Union Fined $1.5 Million for Mishandling Online Banking Migration

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) has imposed a $1.5 million penalty on VyStar Credit Union due to significant issues arising from its recent online banking migration. VyStar, serving over 980,000 members, has been directed to pay this fine into the CFPB’s victims relief fund. The credit union is also required to reimburse members who incurred fees or costs due to the migration’s failures, ensuring that they are fully compensated.

In 2022, VyStar launched a new online banking platform, intending for the transition to result in only a brief service interruption. However, the platform crashed soon after its release. The CFPB investigation revealed that VyStar brought the system online prematurely, without adequate processes to ensure a smooth transition. Although the platform was eventually relaunched, it was missing essential banking services, some of which took months to restore. This left many members unable to manage their accounts, faced late fees due to missed online bill payments, and, in some cases, were unable to access their funds.

“VyStar and its senior management mishandled the rollout of a critical banking system, leaving customers without online access to their accounts,” stated CFPB Director Rohit Chopra. “VyStar’s carelessness resulted in financial harm to its members.”

Todd Harper, chairman of the National Credit Union Administration, emphasized, “Credit unions must put members first, yet VyStar’s diligence fell significantly short during this platform transition. The management’s failures led to consumer harm that lasted not just for weeks but months, creating strategic, reputational, legal, and compliance risks for the credit union.”

The CFPB’s actions highlight the importance of proper planning and risk management in digital platform transitions to safeguard member access and trust.